Image by Douglas Sheppard

Insurance Since 1871

Family Owned
& Operated

Family owned and operated independent insurance agency protecting families and businesses since 1871

Experienced Team

Fully staffed veteran team with over 70 years of combined insurance industry experience

Access to
40+ Providers

Access to over 40 top-rated insurance companies allowing us to offer competitive personal and commercial lines quotes to best fit your insurance needs

Located in Oyster Bay, NY

Located in the beautiful town of Oyster Bay, NY and open Monday through Friday from 8:30am-4:30pm ET - also available after hours by appointment

Licensed in 7 States

New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Florida, Pennsylvania, Colorado, California

Your Trusted Insurance Advisor

Our #1 priority is protecting you and the things you value most - we look forward to welcoming you to our BRC family

Request a Free Quote


We've received your submission and will be in touch soon!

Insurance Coverages We Offer

Select Insurance Companies We Have Access To

utica national insurance.png
Mercury Insurance.png
Swyfft Insurance.png
American Collectors.png
kingstone insurance.png
Markel Insurance.jpg

Our Customers Are Our Priority

Our #1 priority is protecting you, your family and the things you value most. We want to learn more about your personal situation, identify your dreams and goals, and understand your tolerance for risk. Long-term relationships that encourage open and honest communication have been the foundation of our success with our customers and insurance companies since 1871.

"I have been with BRC for more than 20 years. Their team is second to none. Always happy, helpful and responsive!!"

"I am a decades long customer and would not even consider moving my business. The level of service is always at the 'exceeds expectations' level."

"Anytime I have called for Insurance certificates to be sent out, it was done quickly and professionally. I also like the emails sent to me about updates. The staff are always polite and helpful."

"Brooks Robb & Callahan has been my insurance agent for 30 years and has delivered nothing less than top notch service. Home, auto, and marine - they’ve handled it all for me. Their knowledge, honesty, and professionalism makes them an invaluable asset in today’s world."