Independent Insurance Agency Located in Oyster Bay, NY

Custom Insurance Solutions

At Brooks Robb & Callahan, we provide comprehensive personal and commercial insurance policies protecting what matters most to individuals, families and businesses

Insurance you can count on from a team you can trust

Brooks Robb & Callahan is a family-owned and operated independent insurance agency helping customers protect their homes, cars, businesses and more with customized insurance solutions since 1871.

Personal Insurance

Homeowners, auto, boat, motorcycle or anything else, we can help.

Business Insurance

Empower your business's future with customized solutions.

Specialty Insurance

We can also help you with specialty insurance products.

Why Brooks Robb & Callahan?

The Independent Agent Advantage

As an independent agent, we do the shopping for you. We have access to dozens of top-rated insurance carriers, which means we can compare coverage and pricing to find the best fit for your unique needs. Unlike captive agents who work for a single company, we work for you—ensuring you get the right protection at the right price.

Picture5

We're Rated 5-Stars on Google

Even more reasons to choose Brooks Robb & Callahan if you live in Oyster Bay or surrounding areas.

Choosing the right insurance policy can be a daunting task even for a well-informed consumer.

 

At Brooks Robb & Callahan, our main goal is to make the process as easy, educational, and enjoyable as possible. We provide personalized and authentic advice from experienced agents, who are positioned to “go to bat” for our clients, putting your interests front and center each and every day.

 

Our team works and lives in your community right alongside you, and we pride ourselves on providing immediate access to licensed and trained professionals.  You’ll never be transferred to a call center or robot reading a script trying to service your insurance needs.

 

You're never just a number at Brooks Robb & Callahan!

Choice

Being Independent means that we don't work for any one insurance company. We have the ability to search multiple companies on your behalf, acting as a negotiator, to find you the best possible policy and price. You never have to haggle with an agent or insurance company again.

Expertise

Not all insurance agencies are created equal. We have an in-depth knowledge of insurance policy coverages from dozens of different insurance companies. We've seen it all, and when it comes to fine print, we truly understand the coverage we are recommending.

Service

Why sit on hold with a call center representative who doesn't know you, when you can deal with a familiar face who knows you and understands your unique situation? Our customer service is the single biggest reason why our customers refer us so many of their friends.

Claims

The entire reason you have insurance is for when you need to use it. Unfortunately, insurance contracts contain many exclusions and conditions you may be unaware of. We'll help you understand how you're covered, and walk you through your claim.

Local

When you do business with our agency, you're not only supporting your local community, but you're being serviced by a local business who knows your name, and your unique coverage needs. You never have to deal with call-center representatives again.

Let's talk insurance

Our process is designed to make insurance simple, transparent, and stress-free.

Our Top Priority

Our #1 priority is protecting you, your family, your business and the things you value most. We want to learn about your personal situation, identify your dreams and goals, and understand your tolerance for risk. Long-term relationships that encourage open and honest communication have been the foundation of our success with customers and insurance companies since 1871.  We strive to be viewed by our customers as "The Best Insurance Agency on Long Island!"

Have questions about the process of switching to us?

Get answers to some frequently asked questions below.

(cropped) Office Photo (no shadow)-custom-1000x1000

Protecting Your Legacy

(Cropped) Small-D85_3920-Edit

Our Purpose

At Brooks Robb & Callahan, our purpose is to protect what matters most to our clients by providing comprehensive and tailored insurance solutions. As an independent agency, we are committed to offering expert guidance, exceptional service, and a wide range of coverage options to meet the diverse needs of individuals, families, and businesses. We strive to build lasting relationships based on trust, integrity, and reliability, ensuring our clients have the confidence and security they need to thrive.