top of page
SCM Agency

SCM Agency has merged with Brooks Robb & Callahan. For additional information regarding this merger, including a message from Steven C. McCarty, please click here.

Your Local Independent Insurance Agent For Life

Brooks Robb & Callahan is a family owned and operated, independent insurance agency offering customized property and casualty insurance solutions to clients since 1871

Request a Free Quote

We've received your submission and will be in touch soon!

Office Photo (no shadow)_edited.jpg
Suburb Houses_edited_edited_edited_edited.jpg

About Us

Our #1 priority is protecting you, your family and the things you value most. We want to learn more about your personal situation, identify your dreams and goals, and understand your tolerance for risk. Long-term relationships that encourage open and honest communication have been the foundation of our success with our customers and insurance companies since 1871.  We strive to be viewed by our customers as "The Best Insurance Agency in Oyster Bay!"

Trusted Choice Insurance
Demotech Insurance
5 Stars
AM Best Insurance

Custom Insurance Policies Designed For You

We're Proud of Our 5-Star Google Rating

5 Stars

Joe I., Insured

Do yourself a favor and give Brooks Robb & Callahan a call.  I had been using GEICO for years for my auto, home, umbrella, and motorcycle insurance. BRC was able to provide me with better coverage and at a much more competitive rate on all policies. In all, I will save close to $2000 in the next year because I switched to Brooks Robb & Callahan, and the customer service was outstanding…

Cleadous M., Insured

This is an excellent agency. From top to bottom, everyone whom you may encounter is there to help you.  They will find the most inexpensive, yet safe route for your insured valuables. They will do everything that they can to make you a very satisfied customer.   Thank you for all that you do for our practice and for our home.

Brad B., Insured

Despite having worked for insurance companies for over 40 years, I don't know all that much about auto and homeowners insurance.  Brooks Robb & Callahan takes time to explain policies and different options.  They represent several insurance companies and really seek out the best fit for my needs.  If you're thinking about going to a direct writer like Geico or Allstate to save a couple dollars, DON"T.

Family Owned

& Operated

Family-owned and operated independent insurance agency in Oyster Bay, NY protecting families and businesses since 1871

Select Insurance Companies We Can Access

A Central
ACE Insurance
AIG Insurance
American Collectors
AMTrust Financial
Andover Companies
Adirondack Insurance
Cabrillo Coastal Insurance
Chubb Insurance
CNA Surety
Encompass Insurance
Farmers Insurance
Berkshire Hathway Guard Insurance
Hanover Insurance Group
Harleysville Insurance Logo
The Hartford Insurance
Kemper Insurance
Merchants Insurance Group
Hagerty Insurance
Naragansett Bay Insurance
NYPIUA Insurance
NYCM Insurance
Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company
Progressive Insurance
Pure Insurance
Scottsdale Insurance Company
Tapco Insurance
Travelers Insurance
Utica First Insurance
USLI Insurance
Utica National Insurance Group
UPC Insurance
Plymouth Rock Assurance
Mercury Insurance
Velocity Insurance
National General Insurance
Kingstone Insurance
Markel Insurance


Assurant Flood Insurance
National Flood Insurance Program
Wright Flood Insurance
Aon Edge Flood Insurance
bottom of page